AMERICA’S POLICING DILEMMA

The question, I suppose, is this. At what point should the penny have dropped for the Jews of Europe? When should they have started shooting the authorities at the door rather than come along peacefully? It’s easy to say in retrospect, but retrospection wasn’t widely available until about the time of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising.

There’s a question similar in kind – albeit clearly not in degree – for black men in America. And in the wake of the George Floyd killing, it’s been asked and answered by the shooting of white cops. As of last night, the count was six.

Are these the opening salvos of a race war? Clearly not. But these shootings do put white police officers on notice. They’re on notice that, what’s written on the cruiser’s bumper notwithstanding, for some of the people they’re “the enemy of the people”. Which people? Black people. Which black people? Easy to say in retrospect, but retrospection isn’t available at the moment a black man is approaching the police car. The cop’s guard goes up. Another unarmed black man goes down.

The so-called left –  Democrats, CNN, MSNBC, and so on – sympathize, and rightly so, with the unarmed black man. The so-called right – Republicans, Fox, and so on – sympathize, and rightly so, with the cop. The balance between these sympathies will have some effect on the results in November. But those results can have no effect on this dynamic. That’s because what Hobbes called ‘diffidence’ – our fear of the other’s fear – is built into us. And for good evolutionary reasons.

Biden’s solution is community policing. Police should be members of the particular neighborhood they serve. But that doesn’t help when a black man goes jogging down a white street. Well then, don’t. But that just reinforces segregation. Hence America’s national prayer: the Serenity Prayer.

Not Canada’s. Were I an orthodox Jew, my first prayer in the morning is supposed to be, “Thank God I was not born a woman.” I’m not orthodox. Mine is, “Thank God I was not born an American.”

3 thoughts on “AMERICA’S POLICING DILEMMA

  1. Biden’s solution is community policing. Trump’s solution is to send in the army. But under the US Constitution both solutions are irrelevant because local policing is under municipal jurisdiction.

    Only if the municipality absolutely can’t handle the crisis can the State send in its troops. But not the Feds.

    So it’s easy for Biden and Trump to offer solutions to situations outside their control, because they will never have to see if their solutions actually work. And, as an added bonus, they can criticize everyone who has the jurisdiction to deal with the issue for failure to adopt their so-called solution. That means CNN will give Biden lots of media coverage for his irrelevant solution, while Fox will do the same for Trump.

    Like

Leave a Reply to Andrew Roman Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s